Gluten-Free Stuffed Cookies
Our indulgent stuffed cookies are inspired by the famous Amish bakery treats found in the markets of Lancaster, known for their generous size, soft texture, and rich fillings. Each cookie is handcrafted to create a bakery-style dessert with a tender cookie exterior and a delicious surprise filling inside.
All of our stuffed cookies are gluten-free and made with carefully selected ingredients for exceptional flavor and texture.
Cheesecake stuffed cookies contain dairy due to the cheesecake filling. You may choose “Gluten-Free Only,” which uses real butter, or select a dairy-free option made with organic palm shortening.
Our non-cheesecake stuffed cookies are dairy-free, soy-free, and gluten-free, though they do contain eggs for structure and texture.
We proudly bake without artificial food dyes, corn syrup, soy flour, or soybean oil, focusing on simple ingredients and quality baking.
Ordering & Pickup Instructions
Please write any allergies along with your requested pickup date and time in the Notes section at checkout, or click Edit Cart to add your preferred pickup details.
We typically require 72 hours notice for orders. During the holidays—especially Thanksgiving and Christmas—we require seven days notice to properly prepare and complete your order.
Rush Orders & Cancellation Policy
-
Orders requested for the next business day may not always be possible; if accommodated, a $25 rush fee will apply.
-
Orders needed within two days may incur a $20 rush fee if we are able to fulfill them.
-
Orders cancelled within 2 days of the scheduled pickup will forfeit the deposit.
